5 Reasons Insurance Companies Deny Injury Claims in New Mexico
Getting a denial letter from an insurance company after an injury is frustrating, especially when you are dealing with medical bills and time away from work. A denial is not always the final word, though.
Here are five common reasons insurance companies deny injury claims in New Mexico, and what you can do about each one.
1. The Insurer Disputes Who Was at Fault
The most common reason for a denial is a dispute about fault. The insurer may claim its policyholder was not responsible, or that you caused the crash or fall.
What you can do: Gather evidence that shows what happened, including the police report, photos, video, and witness statements. Remember that New Mexico follows pure comparative fault. Even if you were partly at fault, you can still recover a reduced amount.
2. The Insurer Says Your Injuries Are Not Serious, or Not Related
Insurers often argue that your injuries were minor, caused by something else, or existed before the incident. Gaps in treatment or a delay in seeing a doctor make this argument easier for them.
What you can do: Get medical care promptly, follow your doctor’s treatment plan, and keep your appointments. A pre-existing condition does not bar a claim. If the incident made a condition worse, that harm may be compensable.
3. Missing Information or Missed Deadlines
A claim may be denied because a form was incomplete, records were not provided, or a deadline was missed. Some deadlines, like the 90-day notice requirement for claims against government entities, are strict.
What you can do: Respond to insurer requests in writing, keep copies of everything you send, and track every deadline. In New Mexico, most injury lawsuits must be filed within three years.
4. Coverage Disputes
The insurer may say the policy does not cover the incident. Examples include claims that the driver was not listed on the policy, the vehicle was being used for business, the policy had lapsed, or an exclusion applies.
What you can do: Ask for the specific policy language the insurer is relying on. Coverage questions can be complex, and other policies, such as your own uninsured motorist coverage, may still apply. Read our post on the pitfalls of minimum limits coverage.
5. Statements or Social Media Used Against You
A recorded statement given too early, or a social media post that seems to show you active, can be used to justify a denial or a low offer.
What you can do: Decline to give the other side’s insurer a recorded statement until you have talked with a lawyer, and stay off social media about your injuries. See our article on insurance company tactics.
Your Rights Under New Mexico Insurance Law
New Mexico’s Insurance Code prohibits unfair claims practices (NMSA 1978, § 59A-16-20). Among other things, insurers must:
- Respond reasonably promptly to communications about claims
- Conduct a reasonable investigation before denying a claim
- Try in good faith to reach prompt, fair settlements when liability is reasonably clear
- Explain the basis for a denial or a compromise offer
When an insurer violates these rules, the people affected may have additional legal remedies. You can also file a complaint with the New Mexico Office of Superintendent of Insurance.
What to Do After a Denial
- Get the denial in writing, including the specific reason.
- Request a copy of the policy and any provisions the insurer cites.
- Do not give up or sign anything without understanding your options.
- Keep gathering evidence and medical records.
- Talk to a lawyer about whether the denial can be challenged or whether a lawsuit is needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I still file a lawsuit if the insurance company denied my claim?
Yes. A denial from the insurer does not decide your legal rights. If the claim cannot be resolved, a lawsuit can be filed against the at-fault party within the deadline.
Does a lowball offer count as a denial?
Not technically, but a very low offer can have the same effect. You do not have to accept it.
What if my own insurance company denied my claim?
Your own insurer owes you a duty of good faith and fair dealing. An unreasonable denial by your own insurer may give rise to additional claims.
Claim Denied? Get a Second Opinion.
The Law Offices of Bill Russell helps injured New Mexicans challenge unfair denials and pursue fair compensation. Call (505) 218-7844 or contact us online for a free consultation.
Not sure what your policy covers?
Attorney Bill Russell is a former New Mexico insurance agent who offers complimentary coverage reviews. Request a free coverage review →
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Every case is different. Reading this post does not create an attorney-client relationship.